Torn, opinions wanted.


Kyria_Shirako

 

Posted

So looking to roll up a new melee toon specifically another Fiery Aura character. I have it narrowed down to a MA/Fire scrapper or a Stone/Fire brute. I'm not 100% up to date on the brute changes, I was thinking they got their base res mods raised or something but when I checked in game fire shield was a 22.5% res for both AT's. So whats the deal with that?

Also, with the fury changes where does that put scrappers vs brutes for damage assuming you are sitting around 50% fury?

Survivability wise both builds I've gotten to around 30-35% S/L/Melee defense the big difference is the brute has fault, the scrapper shadow meld (which will softcap everything else)

So I guess the question is, damage? How's it looking. And survivability, do brutes get anything more than a higher base HP than the scrapper?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MrLiberty View Post
So looking to roll up a new melee toon specifically another Fiery Aura character. I have it narrowed down to a MA/Fire scrapper or a Stone/Fire brute. I'm not 100% up to date on the brute changes, I was thinking they got their base res mods raised or something but when I checked in game fire shield was a 22.5% res for both AT's. So whats the deal with that?
It was a change that they toyed with briefly in beta, then decided against. Both Scrappers and Brutes indeed still have the same base Resistance numbers.

Quote:
Also, with the fury changes where does that put scrappers vs brutes for damage assuming you are sitting around 50% fury?
The fury change didn't alter the way fury affects your damage - it simply made it easier to achieve medium levels and harder to maintain high levels of fury.

Quote:
Survivability wise both builds I've gotten to around 30-35% S/L/Melee defense the big difference is the brute has fault, the scrapper shadow meld (which will softcap everything else)

So I guess the question is, damage? How's it looking. And survivability, do brutes get anything more than a higher base HP than the scrapper?
Damage is now looking rather squarely in favor of the Scrapper.

As for survivability, Brutes get higher HP. They also get a higher HP Cap (3200-some as compared to 2400) and a higher Resistance Cap (90% vs. 75%). Much of the time these latter distinctions are academic, but in the right combination of sets, external buffs, and certain Tier 9 Defense Nukes/Godmodes, it is possible to make a Brute as survivable as a Tanker a proportion of the time.


 

Posted

Cool! Thanks very much for clearing everything up! I've got Fire/SS and Fire/EM tanks atm so I'll probably go for all out damage with the MA/Fire scrapper.