Lazybones

One fix that I can think of would be for the defiance to tick down but not be removed when healed back up.. I know in most big battles my health yo-yo's so every dip below 40% would increase defiance and every attack would use it up.. If I am not taking damage defiance would tick its way back to nothing.

I like the accuracy idea as well but I think it would make it more powerfull then intended.

I haven't had my account active for a long time, so I gave things a go over the free long weekend.

From what I can see I agree with almost everyone else, defiance does not appear to do anything. If your health is below 40% you are probably taking too much damage too quickly for it too help. If you are fighting correctly your health should only dip below 40% once and a while.

Mabe if it kicked in at a different % you would notice it doing something. OR if it was a flat high bonuse at at 40% it would do something you could see.

I just play as if it isn't there, it doesn't seem to improve or detract from my previous play style.